In-Store vs. Online? How 2025 Consumer Shopping Habits Impact Brands

As we navigate a year of economic uncertainty and shifting consumer shopping preferences, ThinkNow’s latest Clicks vs. Carts: 2025 Shoppers Report reveals a nuanced picture of how Americans are shopping in 2025, and what that means for retailers, marketers, and brands looking to stay competitive. The quantitative research report is based on a nationally representative sample of 1,500 consumers from ThinkNow’s market research panels and breaks out the findings by age and ethnicity. Some highlights include:

1. Cautious Optimism Amid Economic Uncertainty

While two out of five Americans believe their finances will improve this year, the country remains split on the broader economic outlook. Inflation remains the top concern across all demographics, especially among older consumers. Millennials and Gen Z are more hopeful about their personal financial future, which is an encouraging sign for brands targeting younger buyers.

2. Shopping Priorities Reflect Economic Caution

In 2025, consumers are prioritizing practical purchases such as smartphones, travel, electronics, and home upgrades. Big-ticket items like homes and luxury goods are on the back burner. More than ever, brands must now focus their messaging on value, durability, and emotional connection.

3. E-Commerce Is Here to Stay, But So Is the Store

Online shopping continues to grow, with nearly half of Americans making online purchases at least once a week. Gen Z and Millennials lead the charge here, with Gen Z showing the highest daily online shopping rates. Still, in-store shopping remains vital—especially for groceries, alcohol, and home goods—proving that omnichannel strategies are essential.

4. Hybrid Shopping Is the New Norm

Clothing and fashion purchases increasingly straddle online and in-store channels, as consumers seek convenience and tactile experience. Millennials are expanding their online habits into groceries and appliances, while Gen Z is driving new growth in beauty and electronics online.

5. Price and Quality Drive Purchases

Across categories, price and quality are the two biggest decision drivers. Brand reputation, customer reviews, and the ability to touch or try products also play a role, especially for big purchases. Speed of delivery and easier returns are crucial levers for increasing online conversion.

6. Amazon Still Reigns, But Niche Retailers Are Gaining Ground

Amazon is the top online retailer, but Walmart and Target are strong contenders, especially among African American and Hispanic consumers. Younger shoppers are also exploring platforms like Shein, Nike, and Instacart, reflecting a broadening of the digital marketplace.

7. Cultural Relevance Matters—Especially in Multicultural Segments

More than half of Hispanic consumers say they sometimes or always look for Spanish-language shopping options. Millennials and Gen X Hispanics also place greater importance on culturally relevant marketing, from language to holiday promotions. For brands, marketing to the nation’s growing Hispanic population isn't a trend—it's a necessity.

Future of Retail: What’s Next?

Consumers see faster delivery, mobile-first shopping, and sustainable options as key trends shaping the future. Gen Z and Millennials are driving interest in social media shopping, while Gen X shows the greatest enthusiasm for immersive retail experiences like AR and VR.

How Retailers Can Win in 2025

To boost online sales, consumers are calling for better discounts, faster shipping, and simpler return processes. This points to a continued expectation for convenience, transparency, and value delivered with cultural fluency and digital agility.

Consumer Shopping in 2025: The Bottom Line

As consumer shopping expectations evolve, brands must adapt strategies that blend price sensitivity, omnichannel experiences, and cultural resonance. Whether online, in-store, or in-between, the shopping journey of 2025 is dynamic and deeply human.

Download the report here.